AMEMSA Justice Collective

The AMEMSA Justice Collective is a new statewide coalition that seeks to advance civil rights protections for Asian , Middle Eastern, Muslim and South Asian communities. The AJC is directed by and accountable to AMEMSA communities and seeks to organize in a grassroots, bottoms-up manner. The AJC project was initiated by Hammad Alam, a brilliant privacy lawyer with the Asian Law Caucus. Oakland Privacy was honored to be asked to help develop the coalition as a trusted ally.

As an initial project, the AJC seeks to develop and advocate for transparency legislation for federal-local partnerships. Such partnerships, which include the Joint Terrorism Task Force and the FBI Safe Streets programs, among others, often serve as an unregulated frontier in policing, since many local criminal justice reforms don’t include the local/federal partnerships. See the fact sheet below for more on the AJC’s work and how you can support it.

* Note: We must share here that AJC’s founder Hammad Alam tragically passed away in early October. His death is a great loss for the privacy and anti-surveillance community, to the Muslim and South Asian communities writ large who he lived to serve, and enormously painful to those of us who knew him as a friend and an unspeakable loss for his family, including his wife and six month old daughter. If you would like to make a donation in his honor to help his wife and daughter, you can do so here.

How are California Fusion Centers Working With Local Law Enforcement Agencies on Situational Awareness Support?

With the explosion of surveillance data being harvested across many different sectors, fusion centers were built to consolidate the multiple streams of surveillance data into information-sharing hubs that include local, state, federal, and private entities. Each state has at least a primary fusion center but can also have other regional fusion centers focused on major metropolitan areas within the state. In California, the primary fusion center is the California State Threat Assessment Center and the state also has regional fusion centers: NCRIC (Northern California), CCIC/STAC (Sacramento), LAJRIC (Los Angeles), OCIAC (Orange County), and SDLEC (San Diego). 

Panel Discussion: Shotspotter Gun Detection Across The Country

In September 2023, anti-surveillance activists from across the country (Chicago, Portland, and Northern and Southern California) came together to discuss gunshot detection and leading manufacturer Shotspotter (now known as “SoundThinking”). The panel was hosted by POP Pasadena and featured Mohammed Tasajar from ACLU-Socal, Aje Amaechi from Freedom to Thrive in Portland, Ed Vogel from the Lucy Parsons Lab in Chicago and Tracy Rosenberg from Oakland Privacy.

You can watch the coversation here!

San Leandro Delays Expansion of ALPR Program

The San Leandro City Council voted 4-3 to reject, for now, a police proposal to double the number of license plate readers in the East Bay town from 41 to 82. The initial 41 were approved in 2022, but just recently were fully installed,

The Council discussion was lengthy (over an hour and a half). We have pulled a few video clips with particularly interesting Q+A below.

CVE/PVE/TVTP: What’s The Latest Version of Homeland Security Terrorism Prevention Programs?

Countering Violent Extremism (CVE), a program developed by the Obama administration, sought to combat radicalization, then defined almost entirely as Muslim-based violent extremism, through using schools and social service agencies to “identify” potential terrorists based on somewhat poorly defined characteristics. The program drew significant opposition on several fronts, including the vague indicators of incipient terrorism, the community-destroying elements of reporting and mutual suspicion, and the criminalization of innocuous behavior.

Versions of CVE continued to circulate through the Homeland Security apparatus, including Preventing Violent Extremism (PVE), a state copycat version that was defunded, TVTP (Targeted Violence and Terrorism Prevention) and the Bay Area UASI (Urban Areas Security Initiative), whose then-law enforcement training program Urban Shield heavily featured exercises illustrating attacks by Islamic extremists. (Urban Shield was discontinued).

In the post-Urban Shield environment, the training program from Bay Area UASI, called BATEP, is undergoing some changes. The somewhat sparse website is here. Oakland Privacy volunteer Devyn Nordstrom decided to check out a free workshop on Terrorist Use of the Internet. The class materials can be seen here.

A summary of the evolution of the terrorism prevention programs over the past decade by Devyn can be read below.

The Pursuit of Folly: ALPRs as a Technological Non-Solution to Crime.

The Berkeley City Council is scheduled to vote on July 25th to install hundreds of thousands of dollars of Automated License Plate Reader equipment (ALPRs) across Berkeley, in the hope of deterring auto thefts and violent crime.

The proposal specifies a two year test period for the equipment, but fails to specify any parameters or methodology for the test, nor any criteria for success or failure. As such, this will not be a scientific test, it is flimflam, smoke-and-mirrors: a procedure that guarantees “success” defined after-the-fact regardless of reality.

But this is not the worst of it. A massive, nationwide test of ALPR efficacy has already been conducted, spanning the last decades.  And it failed.